Choosing a format: exhibit film, oral history or documentary short
What each format is good at, what it asks of your organisation, and which questions settle the choice before you write a brief.
Start with the use, not the format
Say where the story will be seen or heard and by whom before you pick a format: a gallery wall, a website, a school visit, a screening, an archive reading room. The place sets the length, the sound and the way people will meet it.
Exhibit film
- Good for: a gallery, visitor centre or event where people pass through and watch for a short time.
- Built for: silent or captioned viewing in a loop, or a short piece with sound at a set point. It must make sense if someone joins halfway.
- Asks of you: a clear message, rights to every image shown, and a plan for the screen, speakers and maintenance.
Oral history project
- Good for: preserving first-hand accounts from a community, a workplace, a place or a period, and keeping them for researchers and families.
- Built for: recorded interviews, with transcripts, summaries and a catalogued archive. The finished pieces for audiences, such as a listening post or a podcast, come from the archive.
- Asks of you: consent forms agreed with a local adviser, a deposit plan for where recordings will live, and time. The recording is the project; the edit is a second job.
Documentary short
- Good for: telling one story with a beginning and an end, for screenings, festivals, fundraising events and online.
- Built for: a narrative with characters and scenes, an edit, music and sound design, and usually a script or treatment before filming.
- Asks of you: a clear editorial decision-maker, time for the film-maker to follow the story, and a distribution plan for after it is finished.
Questions that settle it
- Do you want people to watch passively, or to listen, search and explore?
- Is the main goal to preserve many voices, or to tell one story well?
- Who will care for the material in five years: do you have a place for the files and the staff to look after them?
- How much of the story still depends on people who may not be here next year?
- Can you share the finished work online, or are there reasons it must stay on site?
You can combine them
Many projects record oral histories first and then cut an exhibit film or a short documentary from the best material. If you do, say so in the brief and in the consent forms from the start, so contributors agree to every use you plan.
Write a brief · What makers publish for prices · Other guides